What Is the Hebrew Roots Movement? Understanding and Refuting It

What is the Hebrew Roots movement?

The Hebrew Roots movement is a teaching that says Christians, including Gentile Christians, should return to the law of Moses as their rule of life. In practice that usually means keeping the seventh day Sabbath, keeping the Old Testament feast days, keeping the dietary laws, and in some groups using Hebrew names for God, insisting on Yeshua in place of the name Jesus, and treating the modern English Bible as unreliable.

The appeal is easy to understand. People want to take the whole Bible seriously. They want to worship the way Jesus worshiped and to feel close to the roots of the faith. Studying the Jewish background of Scripture can teach us a great deal, and learning what the feasts pictured is good and helpful.

The problem is not studying the Old Testament. The problem is the step from studying it to being placed back under it. Hebrew Roots teaching does not only say the law is good reading. It says keeping the law is required, or is at least the fuller and more obedient way to follow Christ, and that churches that worship on Sunday and do not keep the feasts are disobeying God.

To be fair, many people drawn to this movement love Scripture and want to obey God with their whole lives. That desire is right. The question is what God has actually commanded His new covenant people to do, and that question was settled by the apostles themselves.

What did the apostles decide about this?

Scripture quotations are from the ESV.

This is not a new question. It is one of the first questions the early church had to answer. In Acts 15, men came from Judea teaching that Gentile believers could not be saved unless they were circumcised according to the custom of Moses. The apostles and elders met in Jerusalem to consider it, and Peter answered that God gave the Holy Spirit to the Gentiles just as He did to the Jews, that He made no distinction between them, and that He cleansed their hearts by faith. Peter then asked why they would put on the neck of the disciples a yoke that neither their fathers nor they could bear, and said plainly that we believe we will be saved through the grace of the Lord Jesus, just as they will (Acts 15:7 to 11).

The council did not place the Gentile churches under the law of Moses. It sent them a short letter with a few necessary instructions and left the yoke off (Acts 15:28 to 29).

Paul fought the same teaching in Galatia. Teachers had come in behind him telling Gentile believers that faith in Christ was not enough and that they had to add circumcision and law keeping to it. Paul called that a different gospel, which is really no gospel at all (Galatians 1:6 to 9). He said that a person is not justified by works of the law but through faith in Jesus Christ (Galatians 2:16), and he asked the Galatians who had bewitched them into turning back to weak and worthless principles after coming to know God (Galatians 4:9 to 10). He was talking in that passage about observing days, and months, and seasons, and years.

The rest of the New Testament says the same thing in other words. Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to everyone who believes (Romans 10:4). The food laws were a shadow, and Paul warns believers not to let anyone pass judgment on them in questions of food and drink, or with regard to a festival, or a new moon, or a Sabbath, because these are a shadow of the things to come and the substance belongs to Christ (Colossians 2:16 to 17). The feasts were good shadows. They were given to point forward to Christ, and now that Christ has come, going back to the shadow as a requirement is not deeper obedience. It is a step backward.

Hebrews makes the covenant point plainly. In speaking of a new covenant, God makes the first one obsolete, and what is becoming obsolete and growing old is ready to vanish away (Hebrews 8:13). Christians honor the Old Testament as the very words of God. We just read it the way the apostles taught us to read it, as fulfilled in Christ.

Why does it matter?

Because this teaching quietly changes the gospel. If law keeping is required to be right with God, or to stay right with God, or to be a complete believer, then Christ alone is no longer enough. Paul treated that addition as so serious that he pronounced a curse on anyone preaching it, even an angel (Galatians 1:8 to 9). It is not a small style difference between churches.

It also matters inside a home. Families in this movement often end up separated from their own church, because their church worships on the wrong day and eats the wrong food and celebrates the wrong holidays by the new rules. Children can grow up measuring faithfulness by calendars and menus instead of by repentance, faith, and love. And in the stricter groups the pressure only grows, because there is always another Hebrew word to learn, another rule to recover, and another version of the Bible, such as the Cepher named in the resources on our original page, being sold as the one that finally gets it right.

There is a kinder way to handle this with people we love, and we should use it. If you are in a group like this and something feels heavy, talk with your elders first. They are the men God has charged with the care of the flock, and they are the right first stop for questions like these.

Who taught it then, and who teaches it now?

Then, it was the teachers Paul and the Jerusalem council answered in the first century. Scripture does not give us their names. It gives us their message, that Christ plus Moses is required, and it gives us the apostles answer, which still stands.

In the modern era, one precursor stream came through Herbert W. Armstrong and the Worldwide Church of God, which taught that Christians must return to Old Testament law, including Sabbath and feast keeping. That movement was not identical to Hebrew Roots as it exists today, and Armstrong should not be stretched into something he was not. But much of the modern appetite for law keeping in American religion passed through his teaching, and many later groups grew up in soil he had tilled.

Today the teaching spreads mostly through online ministries and conferences rather than through a single church. Michael Rood, who leads A Rood Awakening, is one of its best known voices and teaches feast keeping and a return to the Torah as the walk of the believer. Jim Staley, who leads Passion for Truth Ministries, teaches the same return to the law for Gentile believers. Rico Cortes, who leads Wisdom in Torah, teaches Torah observance as the pattern for the Christian life. Mark Biltz, pastor of El Shaddai Ministries, became widely known for teaching about the feasts and for his blood moons teaching, which tied the feast calendar to prophecy. Teaching ministries such as 119 Ministries publish a steady stream of videos arguing that the law of Moses still binds Christians today.

Different teachers in this movement disagree with each other about details, and some go further than others into sacred name teaching and into rejecting Paul. That range is worth noticing. Once a believer is told that the plain teaching of the apostles in Acts and Galatians is not the final word, there is no stable place to stop.

How can our family spot it?

Ask five questions about any teaching that urges a return to the law.

Does it insist on Yeshua and similar Hebrew forms in place of the name Jesus, and treat the name Jesus itself as a corruption or a compromise? The Hebrew form of our Lord's name is no sin to use, and some believers simply love it. But a teacher who will not say Jesus, and who corrects the people who do, is usually drawing from this teaching, and it is often the first visible sign of it.

Does it make feast days, Sabbath keeping, or dietary laws a test of obedience or of being a serious believer? The apostles refused to place that yoke on Gentile Christians, and we should refuse it too.

Does it treat Sunday worship, or Christians who do not keep the feasts, as disobedience? That judgment is exactly what Paul warned against in Colossians 2.

Does it make you doubt your English Bible and push a special version, a special Hebrew name, or a special teacher as the key to finally understanding? A teaching that needs you dependent on its own resources is selling more than it is shepherding.

Does it add anything to Christ as a requirement? Circumcision then and Torah observance now are the same shape of error. If faith in Christ needs a supplement to count, the supplement has become the point.

Watch the short version

We are making short videos on these movements and errors so families can learn to spot them quickly: [link to the Hebrew Roots short to be added once it exists]

This post belongs to our Defend and Contend overviews, written so parents can teach their children why the church has answered these teachings the way it has. The set also includes Kenosis, the Seeker Sensitive Movement, Mormonism, the New Apostolic Reformation, the Prosperity Gospel, and Roman Catholicism [links to be added as the set is built]. Teaching our children that Christ has fulfilled the law, and that we receive Him by faith alone, is one of the best defenses there is. The old writers help here too, because men whose works have been tested by the church for centuries will keep pointing a family back to the finished work of Christ and to the plain teaching of the apostles, long after the latest online ministry has moved on to its next discovery.

Further reading

Cultish Podcast - Answering Claims of Hebrew Roots part 1

Cultish Podcast - Answering Claims of Hebrew Roots part 2

What is the Hebrew Roots movement? (GotQuestions)

Hebrew Roots: About that Cepher "Bible" (Berean Research)

Martin Luther, Commentary on Galatians (free, Monergism)

A Field Guide on False Teaching (Amazon)

J. C. Ryle, Warnings to the Churches (Amazon)

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Previous
Previous

Teacher to Avoid: William Paul Young, Author of The Shack

Next
Next

Defend & Contend -Understanding and Refuting the Prosperity Gospel